Review of the Good Doctor Islands Part Two
I'm taking points off because this episode is just also deplorable.
No, I kid, but this really is one of the more than sobering episodes of The Good Doc. Katie and Jenny, conjoined twins who take now been separated, are out of surgery. Jenny wakes up – Katie doesn't. It's up to what's left of the surgical team to figure out what to exercise.
A really peachy moment that I appreciated is when Jenny asks her female parent for water ice chips and her mother leaves the room, and Jenny is struck by the realization that she is alone for the very first time in her life. The panic and fear sets in in a pretty unforgettable moment.
How scary would that exist? You have never been alone, not ever, since birth. As hard as their situation was, Jenny e'er had someone there with her through everything, and now she has to deal with the alien experience of complete solitude. I imagine it's like what being out in outer infinite would be like – all that isolation crushing in on you lot. I'm glad the writers took the fourth dimension to admit that moment.
Meanwhile, Shaun waltzes in, having returned from his road trip with Lea, and announces that he volition be handing in his two-week find. It's a prissy shock for the end of the teaser, but, as I idea about information technology more, I realized it wasn't going to happen. Nosotros're mid-season at present; the writers have spent so much fourth dimension setting up the characters at this infirmary, information technology would make no sense to start all over again somewhere else.
All the same, it's interesting to see how the other characters react – it was especially touching to see Claire tell Shaun that she would miss him.
Claire doesn't get enough credit for existence the heart of the team. I loved at the end when Shaun comes in to Dr. Glassman's office, subsequently the whole kerfuffle with him leaving and wanting the recommendation letter, drops the letter on the desk and simply says, "I spoke to Claire," and and so just leaves.
Dr. Melendez has praised Claire as the team'due south all-time communicator, and that's true with the doctors as well equally with the patients. It was Claire who thought of placing Katie with Jenny overnight and then Jenny would concur to another surgery that would save her life; it's also Claire who knows exactly what to say to pretty much anyone on medical staff who comes to her with a problem. Dr. Melendez found himself opening up to her about his complications with Jessica; Claire knew exactly what to say to Dr. Glassman to take him sign the letter and grant Shaun the freedom he wants; and it took one conversation with Claire to have Shaun decide to stay at the hospital after all. Shaun may accept genius-level medical cognition, but Claire tin read people, and that'due south but as important every bit the medical expertise she also possesses.
The only bad affair about this episode is that is has no suspense. There are moments of tension, and there is momentum, merely ultimately we know from the onset that i of the twins is going to dice – we only don't know which one. Paralleled with the knowledge that Shaun won't leave subsequently all, it kind of deadens the episode in that nosotros know what's going to happen, we just don't know how we're going to get there. The show gets points for presenting a situation that is heartbreaking – a mother having to decide to, in essence, kill one daughter to save the other – and emotionally affecting, but it loses its impact because we know what the finish of the episode is going to be. I promise next week the last outcome won't exist telegraphed quite so much.
The episode ends on Jared rejoining the team later on suing the hospital. It'southward awkward, to say the to the lowest degree, and we know from Shaun's experience that when Dr. Melendez says, "Jared, you're on suction," that means he's currently at the bottom of the pecking guild.
I can't say I'1000 thrilled to have Jared back, as he was never ane of my favorite characters, and, like Dr. Andrews said, he went through questionable means to get his job dorsum. I wonder if in the weeks to come he'll starting time regretting returning to his old job.
Season one, Episode 12 (S01E12)
The Practiced Medico arrogance Mondays at 10PM on ABC
Read all of our reviews of The Skillful Md hither.
Read our reviews of more than of your favorite shows here.
Cailin is a screenwriter and an aspiring Television set writer. When not writing, she's busy convincing random passersby that Firefly was the best prove e'er, converting her co-workers into Whovians, and waiting for the adjacent season of Sherlock.
Follow Cailin on Twitter: @sherlocked1058
Keep up with all of Cailin's reviews here.
Cailin Coane | Correspondent
Source: https://www.tracking-board.com/the-good-doctor-review-islands-part-two/
0 Response to "Review of the Good Doctor Islands Part Two"
Post a Comment